I can't compare Illy to anything else and I'm no expert, but I think this forum is a good idea.
There's a lot promised, hints, suggestions, and inevitably we want it all NOW. I'd like to see more trickle-feed new features, perhaps even ones that the devs don't tell us about and we have to find ourselves! I know we haven't solved all the quests, perhaps the remaining ones are simply too difficult ?
What do I like most? I like Illy is an environment that we, real people, live in. It has straightforward rules, like gravity (I buy something in the market, it arrives. I harvest resources, they run out). And it has a whole lot of person-to-person interaction (I'm nice to someone, they are nice back. I'm rude, they send an army).
What do I most want? Well I'd really like user scripts. I write quests for my Alliance, and some of the steps are that they send a particular gift, and I send a clue back. The logistics are frightening - 70 mails to send out in the right order with the right text. I'd like a script that spots the strange delivery and sends the appropriate response. Perhaps I could write quests for the whole of Illy if the logistics were easier? Oh OK, nobody else wants me to do this
And what's great?
* fantastic artwork. As Kilo put it - the artwork is more detailed than it needs to be, but then so is the game. There are depths that will take a long time to explore
* the building update really adds another dimension - instead of just serving time and getting everything up to level 20, we now have to choose because we can't have it all
* the GMs coming on General Chat - that's just amazing!
* feedback forums like this one - oh and thanks to the GMs for doing stuff so the Race worked when I'd only been on a week!
* everyone. Rill, Kilo, just everyone!