Actions against Myll of [Wave]

I understand how some may look at it as extreme.  But the complete unwillingness to discuss moving the cities and the firm stance that they will continue to do it regardless of what anyone else expects put an end to our negotiating the point.  We could have like some have said, escalated in steps. Used diplomatic attacks, but what are thieves/spies/assassins really going to accomplish?  Plus, we had no desire to drag their whole alliance into a back and forth that would carry on and on.  This is what would have happened if we started going after the individual towns.  

Myll declared on his alliances profile that they are Not a peaceful alliance.  He says that they will wage war when beneficial to their claims.  How is using the same kind of force that they propose on their alliance page so far out of order?  Especially, since we are limiting our penalty to the one player who is promoting the issue. 

Flavius Aetius wrote: I don't believe it's the policy itself that is being enforced, but how the policy is being enforced.

I don't really understand the logic of this argument. At first you condemned WAVE's actions for being outside the community accepted norms of Illyriad. Then, when people were critical of your raze intentions (which are also outside community accepted norms), you justify them by speculating about the meaning of statements on WAVE's alliance profile. If the entire cornerstone of your justification is the violation of community consensus, then violating community consensus seems like an awfully strange way to proceed.

I have no particular objection to you flattening this dude. I object to the elaborate dog-and-pony shows that seem to be part of Illyriad warfare. Brids is right, this should have been done quietly and without forum posts. I've rarely seen anything positive come from PR-style statements on the forums.

What's to discuss? penalize the offending player and if his alliance wants to alter his behavior as a means of protecting him from his consequences then by all means, discuss it between alliances. Raze away - but be willing to allow the player to move his city as he should have in the first place. Lesson learned, on with life.

Hi Everyone

TanyaFairy wrote: Hi Everyone we will next target Myll's alt. After that we will  target the next alliance leader....whoever that may be.

TanyaFairy wrote: Hi Everyone Our action is solely against Myll

So are you solely targeting Myll or not?  You seem to be saying two different things.